The Connection Between Women CEOs and Stock Prices

On August 11, 2020, Presidential candidate Joe Biden announced Kamala Harris as his running mate - marking the first time in history a woman of color has run for vice president in the United States. While the world has seen an increase in women assuming leadership positions across the board, senior positions in large corporations are still primarily dominated by men. In fact, for every one company run by a woman, 13 are run by men.¹ Yet, companies run with women at the helm tend to follow a similar trend - improved performance and rising prices in stocks.

A Reminder About the Gender Gap

Women account for 50.8 percent of the total population in America, and about 47 percent of the workforce.^2,3 Therefore, proportionally speaking, women should account for nearly half the management positions available.

Despite a growing number of women in C-suite positions, the gender gap is still prevalent in America and other developed countries. As of 2019, for example, women employees represented 21 percent of C-suite executive positions - meaning more than three-quarters of these positions are filled by men. What’s more, only four percent of those women were women of color.¹ 

Numerous studies have shown the benefits of having diverse women in leadership and c-suite positions. Here’s what we know about companies run by women and their correlating levels of performance - especially by the six percent of women-led S&P 500 companies.⁴

Evidence Supporting Women in Leadership

Studies around the globe have shown an interesting correlation between the incorporation of women in executive leadership roles and positive performance trends.

A study reported by the Harvard Business Review, for example, concluded:

“Going from having no women in corporate leadership (the CEO, the board, and other C-suite positions) to a 30% female share is associated with a one-percentage-point increase in net margin — which translates to a 15% increase in profitability for a typical firm.”⁵   

Other studies have suggested that while women CEOs on their own may not perform better or worse than their male counterparts, bringing more women into multiple management positions can create a positive impact on performance. 

Another study conducted by S&P Global found that in the two years following their appointment, “female CEOs saw a 20 percent increase in stock price momentum.”⁶ Additionally, companies with more gender diversity on their executive board were more profitable than those without.⁶

Why Does Female Leadership Lead to Better Performance? 

Truthfully, there is no concrete answer to this question. There are, however, theories as to why putting women in executive positions can increase stock performance and profitability.

Theory #1: Few Women Make It To the Top

As the numbers have shown, few women make it into executive leadership and C-suite positions. Therefore, the women who do make it into these roles are often the most motivated, dedicated and hard-working in their field. They excel enough in their fields to beat the odds and outperform the competition. As a result, the women who do make it to the top are often high-performing and well-positioned to propel the company forward.

Theory #2: Diversity Brings Perspective 

Women, in particular women of color, can bring new perspectives to the table. New ideas can spark positive change, which results in better performance. Opening the doors to a more diverse executive team can bring a much-needed breath of fresh air to any company’s leadership board.

Theory #3: Women Tend to Be More Risk Aware

Men (statistically speaking) take more risk than women. Many are quick to state that means women are too risk-averse, but as women CFPs with majority women clients, our experience tells us women aren't risk-averse, we are usually just more risk-aware! Put somebody under pressure, and these gender differences amplify. One study found that men are more likely to make risky decisions under pressure, while women are less likely to do so.⁷ In terms of leadership positions and profitability, this tendency may work in a woman leader’s favor. 

Whether you’re in charge of appointing the leadership board of your own company or you're an investor looking to make your next move, the statistics shouldn’t be ignored. Women in leadership can bring positive change to a company’s momentum and profitability. And while a person’s gender isn’t the only factor that should be considered when appointing employees, and there is no denying that evidence supports diversity and inclusion when it comes to hiring and promoting.